Utter Utterness
This story is about the Parthenon Marbles—the statuary and other sculptures that belong atop the Parthenon in Athens yet have, for the last two hundred years, resided in the British Museum in London. Utter Utterness is my two cents on the controversy, a bit of fiction hung on the old adage “possession is nine tenths of the law.” That is to say, if the marbles were not physically in Britain, would Britain have even the slightest claim on them? The answer (to anyone without a political axe to grind) is pretty obviously no!
UTTER UTTERNESS
by S. C. Marchere
“We kindly ask you to return the marbles to their rightful home in Greece.”
Ms. Peplos, Greek diplomat, and Mr. Tweeds, British diplomat, had met twice before, at state gatherings on successive years——she tasked with making the yearly formal petition for the return of the Parthenon Marbles from the British Museum in London to their historic home in Athens, and he with making the yearly formal reply that the Elgin Marbles were staying put. The sculptures had been fairly acquired by Lord Elgin, Mr. Tweeds reminded, as he had twice before, and she responded, as she had twice before, that a fair acquisition had been impossible because the sellers were Ottoman occupiers with no authority to allow the ancient marbles to leave Greece.
And, she added for the third time, legality of the transaction notwithstanding, Britain had a moral obligation to return the sculptures to Greece simply because they were her country’s cultural birthright.
But in the end, since Mr. Tweeds had no authority beyond politely receiving and rejecting the petition, nothing of real-world value came of the yearly exchange of arguments——just as nothing had come of it over the decades prior, by prior diplomats. The yearly request-and-denial was no more than a reminder that the Earth had yet again successfully circumnavigated the Sun.
Both Mr. Tweeds and Ms. Peplos had wearied of the routine.
Perhaps it was time for the gods to act?
The fourth meeting of Mr. Tweeds and Ms. Peplos came not a year, rather a mere four months after the third, and not in person, but over the phone. Neither could have managed it face-to-face without laughing. You see, the gods had descended from the clouds to steal away with the wearisome routine of Mr. Tweeds and Ms. Peplos!
The morning before the fourth meeting of our two diplomats, before either even suspected it would occur, Mr. Tweeds had paid a visit to the British Museum, not on official business, rather as an ordinary visitor to that bastion of antiquity. It was sheer coincidence that he should arrive at that moment! Coincidence——is there such a thing when the gods are at work? Mr. Tweeds had been disappointed to find the Parthenon Marbles gallery blocked off by walls of plywood. Predisposed as he was to expect routine, he assumed some scheduled maintenance underway; but that small portion of Mr. Tweeds yet willing to believe in godly meddling encouraged him to press an ear against the wall, to hear something of the curious conversation on the other side.
He gasped. What he’d heard couldn’t possibly be true!
Mr. Tweeds hastily gained access to the gallery on the other side of the sheet of plywood.
The sculptures were gone!
A detective rose from the floor with a tiny crumb of familiar stone on the tip of his raised middle finger. All in the room, including our Mr. Tweeds, leaned forward to examine it closely.
That evening, Mr. Tweeds shared the day’s adventure with a wife delighted to have something extraordinary to discuss with her ordinary husband.
“Why steal such enormous things?” she asked. “Surely the thieves could have pocketed some old jewels and made off all the richer.” Mr. Tweeds chewed, swallowed, and replied with a little shrug. “People want what they want, my dear.”
He answered his suddenly buzzing phone. A message appeared. He gasped. Yet another gasp in a day of many gasps.
“They’ve been found!”
“The sculptures? Where?” his wife asked.
“You won’t believe it!”
Back in his office early the next morning, Mr. Tweeds ordered his staff to depart. He’d been tasked by his superiors with making a phone call that would be, unquestionably, the most absurd of his career, and he did not want anyone listening in, in case his performance went poorly. He shooed away his staff like they were sheep. “Shoo,” he actually said, “go away, take an early lunch and don’t return until afternoon.”
Once assured he was alone, Mr. Tweeds shut and locked his door, returned to his desk, and sat for a long while staring at the phone before him.
Eventually he worked up the nerve to pick it up.
More nerve still to poke it awake.
Another brave poke into his contacts.
There Ms. Peplos’ name awaited him. Was she similarly at her desk, staring at her phone, waiting for the appearance of his name? She had no reason to dread the call, and, furthermore, neither had he. They should both welcome it! Perhaps his anxious hesitation was merely because of the utter utterness of the situation!
Utterly utter utterness!
Mr. Tweeds’ finger spun in an indecisive circle above Ms. Peplos’ name. Could he make it through the call without laughing? Probably not. Would she share in the laugh? Possibly. But what if she had not, like him, cleared her office of eavesdroppers? At a diplomatic level, this was no laughing matter. Not from his perspective, at least. Ms. Peplos could fairly laugh, perhaps, although in his professional capacity he would be expected to receive any lightness on her part as unnecessarily provocative.
At very least, he wouldn’t laugh. Stiff upper lip. A lip carved from marble. The matter was not funny, he told himself with a chuckle.
A minute later, his chuckling finally spent, Mr. Tweeds managed the downward thrust of his hesitant finger onto the little telephone icon below Ms. Peplos’ name.
Into the hands of the gods!
Ms. Peplos had, in fact, been expecting the call, and, like her counterpart, had spent the morning preparing herself to behave appropriately. Could she keep her words in check? Surely she’d laughed enough over the preceding twelve hours to hold her for the length of a phone call.
“Mr. Tweeds, is it?”
“Yes. Is this Ms. Peplos?”
“It is. Before we begin, Mr. Tweeds, may I ask if you are alone?”
“I was about to ask you the same question.”
“I am alone. Are you?”
“Utterly alone.”
“I want to be able to speak candidly.”
“What a treat that would be!”
“You don’t have me on speaker, do you?”
“I do not. Am I similarly in your ear, and your ear alone?”
“Yes.”
“Well then, Ms. Peplos, which of us should begin our absurd dialogue? I’m willing to flip for it.”
“No, the gods have sufficiently played their part,” Ms. Peplos replied. “I’ll start.”
Ms. Peplos peered out her office window into the busy courtyard below, where, at the centre of activity lay bundled in tarps the ancient statuary that had once adorned the Parthenon, and, since 1816, the less majestic plinths of the British Museum, in a gallery now empty but for one tiny crumb of marble.
“Just so I know where your head is at, Mr. Tweeds,” Ms. Peplos began, “let me ask you plainly——do you believe that we had anything to do with the theft?”
“The Greek embassy, you mean?”
“The embassy, the Greek government, yes.”
“I thoroughly believe you innocent, madam,” Mr. Tweeds assured.
“You don’t find the story too utterly unbelievable?”
“Utterly,” Mr. Tweeds admitted, “but I nonetheless believe it. And, if I might add, in addition to finding the story utterly unbelievable, I also find it utterly funny.”
Mr. Tweeds immediately regretted having made the admission. Remember your duty, he reminded himself.
The newspaper laid out on Mr. Tweeds’ desk bellowed the official story at the top of the front page in enormous type: Elgin Marbles Found, followed by, in smaller type: Greek Embassy Claims No Part in Theft.
“I was there when the marbles arrived,” Ms. Peplos explained. “I was having lunch out on the front steps, idly people-watching, when a moving truck pulled up to the lights. I noticed it at first only because it had blocked my view of the other side of the street. When the lights changed, the truck remained still. Cars honked. I could see the driver behind the wheel struggling to get the vehicle moving. More honking, angry motorists yelling. I was glad for the turmoil! A little theatre to help down my lunch.”
Ms. Peplos left the window to circle her office, slowly, running her fingers along the wainscotting, noticing a bit of dust on a fingertip, blowing it away.
“The driver got out, popped the hood, and prodded the motor. The other occupant hung near the open passenger door. A policeman came over to lend a hand, looking around as he neared for the best place for the truck to pull over and get out of the way of traffic.”
Ms. Peplos stopped before a large lithograph of the Acropolis.
“Our groundskeeper noticed the commotion and came out to offer the use of our courtyard. I doubt it occurred to him, or to the driver, or to the policeman, that the moving truck would, by turning onto our drive, legally speaking, be entering Greek jurisdiction. Our man, like the policeman, was merely being helpful. He, one of the moving truck men, and a dozen pedestrians pushed the truck while the driver steered and the policeman kept the way clear.”
“As casually as that?”
“As casually as that!” Ms. Peplos laughed.
She continued her stroll along the wainscotting, discovering still more dust where she hadn’t expected it.
“Having finished my lunch, I wandered over to the open courtyard gate——not to lend assistance, as I know nothing about motors——rather to deposit my lunch refuse in the bin.
“The two men from the moving truck walked straight past me as I stepped into the courtyard——straight past me like I wasn’t there! No eye contact, nothing. They walked off stiffly but quickly——that awkward sort of walk one makes the moment before starting into a run.”
“Both were soon apprehended,” Mr. Tweeds interjected, “but neither had much to confess. They hadn’t been the thieves——just two criminal subcontractors, you might call them, with no knowledge of their cargo’s value——tasked with getting the marbles to the harbour where they were to be buried in the ballast of an old steamer otherwise filled with scrap iron. I don’t have all the details, but it seems as if the boat had planned to meet up with another vessel once well out to sea.”
“Some billionaire, I suppose,” Ms. Peplos suggested, “with a taste for the antique.”
Mr. Tweeds sighed.
“You do realise what I have to request?”
“Yes.”
“It’s the reason for my call. I’m tasked with making the request, you understand——I have no choice.”
“And I have no choice but to receive it,” Ms. Peplos replied.
“We know full well that we’re not getting the marbles back,” Mr. Tweeds continued.
“Possession is nine-tenths of the law, after all,” Ms. Peplos responded. “As you very well know!”
Mr. Tweeds again regretted having spoken so freely. Despite having been delighted with Ms. Peplos’ offer of candour, he had not intended to reciprocate. But he had, unfortunately, forgotten himself in the ease of conversation. Her candour had drawn his out.
Ah well, what’s done is done.
“Off the record,” Mr. Tweeds sighed, “we’re glad to have the marbles gone!”
“Oh?” Ms. Peplos was surprised, more by Mr. Tweeds’ frankness than by his sentiment. She’d long suspected he’d been sympathetic to her cause, but had never guessed he’d ever say it out loud.
“Yes, good riddance to them!” Mr. Tweeds laughed.
He dropped into his chair like he’d fainted. While his body lay slumped back, all the rest of his being floated upward, light as air, soon bobbing along the crown moulding, wonderfully, carelessly free!
“Surely you realise that very few of us here,” he continued with uncommon relief, “even those of us at the top, have ever genuinely considered the marbles to be justly ours. Not just now, but from the very start. Our reasons for keeping them, at least at first, had some trace of merit, but those reasons have been irrelevant for over a century. The marbles should have been returned to Greece long ago.”
“Then why weren’t they?” Ms. Peplos reasonably asked, while examining the latest accumulation of dust on her fingertip.
“For exactly the reason you suspect.”
“The floodgates?”
“We can never open those gates.”
“Your museum would soon be empty.”
“Not just ours!”
“If what you’re saying is true about wanting to be rid of the marbles,” Ms. Peplos began, slowly, as an extraordinary idea took form, “I might reasonably ask if, in fact, your own government hadn’t played some part in the theft.”
This possibility had not occurred to Mr. Tweeds.
“Even the wealthiest oligarch wouldn’t have the resources to make off in the night with a dozen tons of stone from such a guarded location!” Ms. Peplos continued with a laugh.
The laugh set Mr. Tweeds once again back to rights. While he was relieved to have spoken his mind, he regretted the direction into which his candour had steered the conversation, and he sought to redirect it to its purpose, absurd though that purpose was.
“Nonsense,” he responded to Ms. Peplos’ accusation.
He then readied himself to make the request he had been dreading since waking that morning——it has to be made, he told himself, just get it over with!
“Ms. Peplos,” he began, “on behalf of the Crown and the people of Great Britain, I am authorised to thank you for recovering our lost treasure, and...”
He paused to steady his resolve.
The moment of truth!
Or, more accurately, the very opposite of truth, the moment of utter truthlessness! With the stiffest possible upper lip, Mr. Tweeds bravely continued——
“...we kindly ask you to return the marbles to their rightful home in the British Museum.”
THE END
Please consider visiting S. C. Marchere's Amazon Author Page
USA | UK | Canada | France | Spain | Italy | Japan | Brazil | Mexico | Australia | India | Germany/Netherlands
